Trashing Detroit

City of Detroit

It is noble for city cheerleaders to remain positive when talking about redefining Detroit, as they are inclined to do. Even more noble is to first realistically assess the scope of the decline.

images-5One of the best indicators of the desirability and livability of a city, or lack thereof, is the extent to which people are trashing it. In this regard, Detroit may be without equal.

Perhaps more than any other major city, Detroit neighborhoods are generally seen as uninviting, inhospitable and perilously plagued by “underclass” behavior that is characterized by bad attitudes and bad manners.

Residents are subjected to offensive piles of uncollected trash, tires and debris that blight the landscape. Downtown streets are littered with vacant, pre-depression architectural relics in the latter stages of decomposition. The city’s arteries are lined with derelict, ugly, abandoned buildings – aging and ghostly vestiges of a once-thriving business class.

Code violations kill the aesthetic of the community. Because the city fails to properly monitor and maintain thousands of abandoned buildings it owns, these structures pose a threat to the city’s recovery by lowering property values. Many are contaminated eyesores that attract vandals, open dumping and other illegal activities.

So why is this happening?

There is a theory among some social psychologists that community neglect is ritualistically wedded in a kind of perverted sequence. Commonly known as the “Broken Windows” theory, it suggests that people are more apt to exhibit destructive behavior in neighborhoods that appear to be unwatched and uncared for.

The theory goes something like this: If a broken window in a building is not quickly repaired, the rest of the windows will be broken in short order. Just one unrepaired window sends the message that no one gives a hoot, so more broken windows won’t concern or hurt anyone.

Perceptions affect reality. Unattended damaged property does become fair game for people out for fun or plunder. Even the appearance of social disorganization is a predictor that a marginal neighborhood is on the verge of becoming a breeding ground for property defacement, vandalism and abandonment.

It occurs when adults stop admonishing unruly, raucous children, who engage in more graffiti and other  damage. Neighbors lose patience; families move out and litter accumulates. Existing buildings are turned into empty ruins.

It is now big business, for example, for thieves to strip unoccupied, sometimes occupied homes and buildings, taking the bricks, furnaces and the kitchen sink. Shady junkyard dealers abet thieves that plunder and cannibalize equipment and transmission lines for copper and other metals that fetch a high price.

Urban decay is not new. But what is happening today is different in at least two important respects from what occurred 60 to 70 years ago. Back then, Detroiters didn’t have the money or transportation to flee neighborhood problems. Nonetheless, blight and crime had a kind of built-in self-correcting mechanism: the resolve of residents to reassert control over their environment. Although lacking the means to escape the various forms of disorder, people possessed a determination to take back the streets.

Today, flight from the city has become rather easy for all but the poorest of the poor. The remaining “underclass” has little appreciation for community cohesion, so it unwittingly fuels and expedites a permanent out-migration from the city.

It may not be possible to suppress this devastating epidemic and fix — literally and metaphorically –the city’s broken windows. The city simply can’t afford to tear down vacant buildings in numbers that keep pace with the rate of abandonment.

So we bear witness to an irreversible transformation that will strip away all memories of a city where people once proudly wanted to live. Unfortunately, that is one of the consequences of allowing stable neighborhoods to disintegrate into oblivion.

17 thoughts on “Trashing Detroit

  1. Mr. Johnson,

    I’m in agreement with your comments and would suggest that we collectively look at ways to clean up Detroit and stop the “Trashing” Part of that change occurs with sharing the powerful stories that are transforming Detroit, but more importantly individuals. Look at whats going on with the SDBA Graffiti clean ups; the Greening of Detroit’s tree planting efforts and their hiring of local residents that are now taking responsibility for their neighborhoods; the Downtown Y’s programs….

  2. It seems as if the city’s leaders over the past couple of decades have been in some sort of suspended animation, and when they woke up, look what’s been wrought.

    I’m not sure which is worse–the broken windows mentality, or that it’s been allowed to get this bad.

    Cities don’t become vessels of gutted out, stripped homes at the rate that Detroit is, overnight.

  3. Wonderful!!! Bookmarked this page which has this particular striking assistance. Is to see if there are any kind of improvements. A person, the author, are a master. Many thanks

  4. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt donate to this brilliant blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this site with my Facebook group. Talk soon!

  5. Hi, I’m a college English student and I’m learning a lot about writing by viewing blogs. I really enjoy your style of writing. It’s simple to understand but with excellent details. Your choice of words makes it easy to read and absorb. That’s a huge part of writing. Your readers have to be able to understand what you’re conveying to them and the publication has to be engaging. You need to engage your readers, so they will come back again. You do a great job with all of these aspects. Thx!

  6. Fantastic weblog! I truly like how it? s straightforward on my eyes also because the information are well written. I’m questioning how i might be notified when a brand new submit continues to be created. I have subscribed for your rss feed which will need to do the trick! Possess a good day!

  7. I don’t typically reply to posts but I’ll in this case.
    my God, i believed you were going to chip in with some decisive insght on the finish there, not leave it
    with ‘we go away it to you to decide’.

  8. Advantageously, the write-up is in reality the freshest topic on this associated problem. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your upcoming updates. Just saying thanks is not going to just be adequate, for the exceptional clarity in your writing. I will directly grab your rss feed to remain informed of any updates.

  9. weblog arrived up in my search and i impressed by what you might have published on this subject. I’m presently extending my search and for this reason can’t lead further, notwithstanding, I’ve bookmarked your web-site and can also be returning to keep up with any approaching updates. Simply adore it and thank you for tolerating my remark.

  10. Thank you for the blog site publish it turned out extremely helpful. You really opened my face as We’ve never understood relating to this just before. We have activated for the Rss in order that I will generally the most recent posts.

Comments are closed.